From a brief flick through one edition of the Australian Financial Review this week the following emerged:
1.'if wins the election'??
The commas round 'from time to time' are odd as well.
2. If the price of iron ore fell to US$1.20, we really would be in trouble.
3. The truth is, if the iron ore price fell to US$1.20, we really might want to CUE the violins.
4. Let's hope that the ups really are multiple and that there is only a singular down (or none at all, ideally).
5. Maybe Romney does speak ungrammatically - or maybe this is sloppily edited.
6. Shouldn't the arrangements be plural?
7. Shouldn't 'half a percentage point' be singular?
8. 'The' NSW?
9. Yes, put the impact in a box and close the lid.
10. Some of whose expansion plans?
When proofreaders go missing: a blog of errors, designed to demonstrate why sub-editors and copy editors remain important, at a time when they are increasingly regarded as optional extras (all contributions welcome; to follow on Twitter - zmkc)
Friday, 21 September 2012
Captions
I'm more than usually baffled by editorial mistakes when they appear in captions. These are such small pieces of text that it seems especially surprising that errors are missed by editors:
1. This is from 'Good Living Street' by Tim Bonyhady - the apostrophe suggests there was a phenomenon called 'the Mahler'
2. These are from the Fitzwilliam Museum's recent exhibition of Chinese tomb contents.
a. 'he may BE one of the nomads'
b. 'on the outer circle' is the start of a new sentence, which suggests a capital 'o' might be in order; 'going into a big mountain AND seeing' might be better than 'going into a big mountain an seeing'
1. This is from 'Good Living Street' by Tim Bonyhady - the apostrophe suggests there was a phenomenon called 'the Mahler'
2. These are from the Fitzwilliam Museum's recent exhibition of Chinese tomb contents.
a. 'he may BE one of the nomads'
b. 'on the outer circle' is the start of a new sentence, which suggests a capital 'o' might be in order; 'going into a big mountain AND seeing' might be better than 'going into a big mountain an seeing'
Wednesday, 5 September 2012
Of and It and the Small Change of Language
The usual advice to savers is 'look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves'. The Australian Financial Review might do well to adjust that adage to its copy editing activities (or lack thereof) - 'look after the little words and the big ones will take care of themselves' (or, more realistically, 'look after the little words and look after the big ones too'):
Misplaced Inverted Commas
The inverted commas around 'fine' are just insulting:
I mean what can they possibly signify other than 'so-called' - 'yeah, all right, some people call these people 'fine', but really they're paedophiles.' Can that really be what the Australian is trying to say?
I mean what can they possibly signify other than 'so-called' - 'yeah, all right, some people call these people 'fine', but really they're paedophiles.' Can that really be what the Australian is trying to say?
The Struggle Continues
Out in Yass, someone's inadequate education leaves them defeated before simple words like 'delight' and 'yolk':
Thank heavens for that 'crusade' the Prime Minister's been on about. Unfortunate choice of words, but things clearly need improving in our schools.
Thank heavens for that 'crusade' the Prime Minister's been on about. Unfortunate choice of words, but things clearly need improving in our schools.
How is this Still Possible?
On the BBC website, despite the existence of spellcheck, someone still manages to spell 'receive' wrong:
Tuesday, 21 August 2012
I Think Len is the Absent Proofreader
Thank you to my brother @Colvinius for passing this on from @greg_shield:
https://twitter.com/greg_shield/status/237764230013677569/photo/1/large
https://twitter.com/greg_shield/status/237764230013677569/photo/1/large
Saturday, 7 July 2012
Not Very Attractive
In an article in the Telegraph about how it has been suggested that women over a certain age should not wear bikinis, the writer claims that she ought to have "brindled" with indignation at this proposition:
It conjures up an interesting image, but I suspect "bristled" may have been the word she was looking for.
It conjures up an interesting image, but I suspect "bristled" may have been the word she was looking for.
A Bunde and Coke Thanks
The Australian Financial Review is fairly expensive. It is supposed to know about financial things (the clue is in the name). Given these facts, it should not repeatedly refer to Germany's central bank as the Bundebank:
Spoctrate
Dear Spectator
You were once a fine magazine; you are now a fine magazine in need of a copy editor. If you don't believe me, just look at these errors, picked at random from your 30 June 2012 issue:
1. "become" is incorrect:
3. Toby Young rather undermines his argument for the kind of education he received by displaying in the phrase "these proposal" his inability to distinguish plural from singular:
4. What are "back accounts" and what does "gave own his own" mean:
5: "more nourishing than", surely - plus grammatically "the reason she preferred it is so she could spend more time" is wrong; it should be "the reason she preferred it is that it allowed her to spend more time":
6. Surely "when you've seen as much and lived as long as Dorothy has" would be the correct way to express what the writer is trying to say:
7. "neigbours" - do you not even have spellcheck:
Possibly you are well aware of all these problems and merely unable to find someone suitably qualified to do the job. If so, let me know. I'd happily take it on (depending on the salary, of course).
Tuesday, 5 June 2012
Sunday, 3 June 2012
Definitely Indefinite
When in doubt, throw both articles in, why not:
and throw in a definite article where it isn't needed too, if you feel like it:
While we're at it, what's one 'of' between friends:
After all, if it's left out in one context, it can always be hurled in randomly in another:
and throw in a definite article where it isn't needed too, if you feel like it:
While we're at it, what's one 'of' between friends:
After all, if it's left out in one context, it can always be hurled in randomly in another:
The Cause of True Love
I think the word should be 'cause', not 'course', but really half the reason I'm putting this in is in order to highlight the context it comes from - Richard Glover's column in this weekend's SMH. It's worth a read, if you want a laugh or two:
Unprincipled
The AFR hasn't even outsourced to New Zealand, but they're already having trouble distinguishing between 'principle' and 'principal':
Thursday, 17 May 2012
Vowel Alert
Sunday, 13 May 2012
Which Member Precisely?
The HSU - Thomson scandal is so unedifying that it is some comfort to know that only one member of the union was actually ripped off:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




































