When proofreaders go missing: a blog of errors, designed to demonstrate why sub-editors and copy editors remain important, at a time when they are increasingly regarded as optional extras (all contributions welcome; to follow on Twitter - zmkc)
Thursday, 17 May 2012
Vowel Alert
Sunday, 13 May 2012
Which Member Precisely?
The HSU - Thomson scandal is so unedifying that it is some comfort to know that only one member of the union was actually ripped off:
Weak Week
Usually, the magazine called The Week is pretty reliable when it comes to typos but recently an article got through that was just a swarming mess of errors:
You have to wonder if drugs were involved, when you find this (told led her):
and this (Not for wanting of trying):
and this (would soon to be shot):
all within one article.
You have to wonder if drugs were involved, when you find this (told led her):
all within one article.
Is Dyslexia a Disability?
Certainly, whoever wrote this caption seems to be suffering from it:
Three cheers for equal opportunities, I suppose.
Thursday, 10 May 2012
Oh No
I'm hoping that the New Yorker has some eccentric style rule that states that 'Nobel', as in Nobel prize, must always be spelt as Noble. If that is not the case, then all is lost - if the New Yorker has started to let mistakes slip through, then civilisation is doomed:
Tuesday, 8 May 2012
Now Now
At the National Portrait Gallery in London they are just as bad at captions as they are at the Art Gallery of New South Wales (see earlier postings):
A Case of Pot and Kettle
When you write about taking your eye off things, it's a good idea to keep your eye on your own words:
(Apologies for the poor quality of this picture - my good camera was temporarily unavailable)
(Apologies for the poor quality of this picture - my good camera was temporarily unavailable)
Saturday, 28 April 2012
Eh?
Wednesday, 25 April 2012
Comma Overboard
I was under the impression that Anzac Day is more keenly observed than ever, but this tweet today from Martin Place in Sydney suggests the public is growing bored of the whole thing:
"Kylie Simmonds @Kylie_Simmonds Close
People stopping taking time to look at wreaths . Lest we forget @ABCNews24 #ANZAC2012 #AnzacDay2012"
Or possibly a comma is needed between stopping and taking time?
"Kylie Simmonds @Kylie_Simmonds Close
People stopping taking time to look at wreaths . Lest we forget @ABCNews24 #ANZAC2012 #AnzacDay2012"
Or possibly a comma is needed between stopping and taking time?
Monday, 16 April 2012
Cambridge, Massachusetts
You know you're near a really good university, when you see this kind of protest in the street:
"Use proper grammar". Not a very familiar phrase in Canberra, more's the pity.
"Use proper grammar". Not a very familiar phrase in Canberra, more's the pity.
Sunday, 4 March 2012
Tossing and Turning
If you are having difficulty getting to sleep because you cannot stop fretting about the erosion of English grammar, it does not help to discover that the herbal remedy you have chosen to help you get to sleep is actually part of the problem:
I remain one of the people 'whom' have difficulty falling asleep - in fact, my problem's worse than ever now.
I remain one of the people 'whom' have difficulty falling asleep - in fact, my problem's worse than ever now.
Saturday, 3 March 2012
Result of the Canberra Education System
I presume 'debris' was the word the signwriter was searching for.
Wednesday, 29 February 2012
English as a Foreign Language
I have rarely been able to resist headlines containing the phrase 'Slain Socialite', and so it was that I found myself on the Fox News site. I had picked up from somewhere the idea that Fox News does not always uphold the highest of journalistic standards, but, really, this appears to have been written by someone who has a very odd understanding of English:
Leaving aside what I would regard as the misuse of 'befuddled' and 'placate', what the hell does 'glommed' mean?
Leaving aside what I would regard as the misuse of 'befuddled' and 'placate', what the hell does 'glommed' mean?
Saturday, 25 February 2012
When Politics Gets Messy
My brother pointed out this, which appeared in an article about the Australian Labor Party that was published in the Guardian:
The democratic world may never have witnessed such murky political behaviour as we have seen during the last week in Australia. Even so, as far as I know, no-one has yet unbarred their holes.
The democratic world may never have witnessed such murky political behaviour as we have seen during the last week in Australia. Even so, as far as I know, no-one has yet unbarred their holes.
Thursday, 23 February 2012
Perspective
Depending on your point of view, Kevin Rudd's inability to proofread his own letter of resignation may support the argument that he is unfit to be Prime Minister or the argument that he should have the job back, so that he can expand his staff to include someone who can proofread things carefully:
Thursday, 16 February 2012
Friday, 27 January 2012
Thank You Drng and Aptronym
It seems that Britain has a new Prime Minister and Surry Hills Library decided to use the dyslexic they hired under equal opportunity to run the publicity for their inaugural spelling bee.
At the Art Gallery of New South Wales
I can't understand what's happened at the Art Gallery of New South Wales. Captions on walls are things that are not rushed into overnight and yet the place is littered with captions containing errors:
Presumably that was meant to read 'and wrote a memoir'.
I'm not mad about a principal passion being 'toward' something, although that is not strictly wrong. However, 'looking for way forward' is.
Shall I be boring again and point out that commas should ideally go round in pairs - there is one missing in the above caption. It should be inserted before the word 'anticipated'. Without it, the sentence is very hard to read.
I'm sorry Mr Capon, this maddens me, because it makes me read the sentence over and over again, puzzling about why it doesn't work. Whatever Edmund Capon actually said, the sentence, for the purposes of the poster, would have read better if edited thus: "This is the great Picasso show to which we have often aspired but which we have not yet achieved in Australia". It is the 'to' which makes things difficult, because the verb 'achieve' does not fit with it. You can't say, 'to which we have not yet achieved' and yet that is how the sentence is structured - as it stands, the verb 'achieved' depends on the clause beginning with that 'to'. It won't do.
Presumably that was meant to read 'and wrote a memoir'.
I'm not mad about a principal passion being 'toward' something, although that is not strictly wrong. However, 'looking for way forward' is.
Shall I be boring again and point out that commas should ideally go round in pairs - there is one missing in the above caption. It should be inserted before the word 'anticipated'. Without it, the sentence is very hard to read.
I'm sorry Mr Capon, this maddens me, because it makes me read the sentence over and over again, puzzling about why it doesn't work. Whatever Edmund Capon actually said, the sentence, for the purposes of the poster, would have read better if edited thus: "This is the great Picasso show to which we have often aspired but which we have not yet achieved in Australia". It is the 'to' which makes things difficult, because the verb 'achieve' does not fit with it. You can't say, 'to which we have not yet achieved' and yet that is how the sentence is structured - as it stands, the verb 'achieved' depends on the clause beginning with that 'to'. It won't do.
Wednesday, 18 January 2012
Cunning Swine
Instead of making sure their signs are written in good English, the people in charge of storyboards on the walk from Taronga Zoo to Balmoral Beach have placed misty sheets of plastic over any offensive bits of prose for which they are responsible, in the hope that no-one will notice - and, if they do, that they won't be able to take photographs of the mistakes. In case it is too difficult to read, I should spell this one out - a permanent sign, paid for by taxpayers, states that Japanese submarines were sighted a certain number of 'metres of the coast'. This is not some quickly dashed off memorandum; this is something designed to be read by the public for years. Why on earth didn't anyone read it carefully? Grrr:
Apostrophe Overboard
'Bradleys' might be considered adjectival and therefore exempt, but 'headlands' is not:
(Personally, I'd put a comma between 'location' and 'providing' as well, but that is a matter of taste, I suppose).
(Personally, I'd put a comma between 'location' and 'providing' as well, but that is a matter of taste, I suppose).
Indian Cricket
This shows that spell-check is not always entirely useless (although it does have to be used, if it is to provide any help). I suppose one should be thankful that an extra 'r' wasn't also added, sending readers screaming from visions of horrible Mr Sting:
The Real Question
What I'd really like to know, though, is whether he still thought Dick Smith would be interested, an entirely different, although possibly easier to understand, question:
Which Four Months Was That?
There was the four months since the four months ago but was that the four months that was after the four months ago or the four months that was before the four months since? Just asking:
I Think They'd Been Drinking
If the people who wrote this hadn't been drinking, why did they suggest that we spend time 'on our' parks? Would it really have taken so much more effort to write, 'on our beaches and in our parks'? I suppose it would have, if your hand was already unsteady from spending the whole day on the turps:
What is that Comma Doing?
The comma before 'a living there', what is its function? Is it, perhaps, a kind of punctuation alternative to a drumroll:
Ebooks Are Bad Enough
Presumably an epublican is the man who fills drinks machines that sell beer and those horrible cans of premixed gin and tonic, et cetera:
What really scares me is the thought of the rise of the emocrats.
Is Consistency Enough
I suppose the argument here is that abandoning the accent on divorcé is okay, if you have already done so on fiancé -but really it would be better, I think, to include both, in order to avoid ambiguity:
Tuesday, 17 January 2012
Thursday, 5 January 2012
Thursday, 29 December 2011
Apostrophe Catastrophe
My Twitter friend Aptronym passed on this piece of illiteracy from the Boxing Day sales. Honestly, did no-one in the company notice?
Monday, 26 December 2011
Commas Again
Why would a meltdown spread to Australia through a series of stress tests?
Or should there, possibly, be a comma between 'Australia' and 'through'?
And are commas being rationed at the Financial Review? Surely one could have been spared, to place after 'fortnight' (and shouldn't that, ideally, be 'of', rather than 'in' in the phrase 'some aspects in the ministerial ...'?
Meanwhile, in the first sentence of this passage, there appears to have been some kind of Georges Perec (La disparition) decision, although, instead of the letter 'e', it is commas that have been targeted for ostracism, (who knows why):
Or should there, possibly, be a comma between 'Australia' and 'through'?
And are commas being rationed at the Financial Review? Surely one could have been spared, to place after 'fortnight' (and shouldn't that, ideally, be 'of', rather than 'in' in the phrase 'some aspects in the ministerial ...'?
Meanwhile, in the first sentence of this passage, there appears to have been some kind of Georges Perec (La disparition) decision, although, instead of the letter 'e', it is commas that have been targeted for ostracism, (who knows why):
Friday, 16 December 2011
Reshuffle those Words
And some who will have trouble forming a proper sentence:
Either, 'The result is there are some ministers who have too much on their plate to possibly be effective and some who ...' or 'The result is some ministers have too much on their plate to possibly be effective and some will have trouble justifying their existence'.
Either, 'The result is there are some ministers who have too much on their plate to possibly be effective and some who ...' or 'The result is some ministers have too much on their plate to possibly be effective and some will have trouble justifying their existence'.
Great Artist, Dud Editor
I'm sad that the attention to detail shown by the featured artist in this magazine was not copied by those in charge of the text.
Saturday, 3 December 2011
Blistering Barnacles
Was the Ancients' name for it censored? Instead of a blank before the bracket, should it read *!!*#*!!, in homage to Captain Haddock:
Semi-Literate
It would have taken so little to transform this:
Wouldn't this be an improvement: 'The fire began burning last week, but late yesterday, fanned by winds gusting at up to 50km/h, it roared out of control, breaking containment lines.'
Wouldn't this be an improvement: 'The fire began burning last week, but late yesterday, fanned by winds gusting at up to 50km/h, it roared out of control, breaking containment lines.'
Batty Headlines
It may be just me, but the impression I get from this one is that someone's been engaging in some dubious sexual practices (what exactly is 'sandbag' a euphemism for, I wonder):
Meanwhile, this one:
even though the article to which it is connected does eventually provide an explanation for that p-word:
fails to achieve the task of a headline - to instantly let most readers know what the article is going to be about.
Meanwhile, this one:
even though the article to which it is connected does eventually provide an explanation for that p-word:
fails to achieve the task of a headline - to instantly let most readers know what the article is going to be about.
More of the Enemy (Ambiguity, I Mean)
Whose wife is being referred to here - Gilham's or Hills's:
Changing the opening line of the second paragraph to 'Gilham's wife, Robecca', (and yes, it appears that is how her name is spelled), would have removed any confusion.
Changing the opening line of the second paragraph to 'Gilham's wife, Robecca', (and yes, it appears that is how her name is spelled), would have removed any confusion.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






